Best Value Teams to Reach the 2026 NHL Playoffs
This piece was written during the NHL's Olympic break in February 2026. The odds and probabilities below are the ones on offer at that time, and we've kept it as a record of how the playoff futures market looked at the break.
While the hockey world watched the men's Olympic tournament in Milan, the NHL futures board barely moved. The league paused from February 6 to February 24, with play resuming on February 25 and the trade deadline following in early March. If you price futures for a living, that quiet fortnight was the last clean window before deadline trades, injuries and model updates shifted the numbers.
The San Jose Sharks were the clearest example. Colorado fans still like to bring up the 2019 playoffs, when the Avalanche won Game 4 of the second round 3-0 by carving up the San Jose Sharks (San Jose went on to win that series in seven). For most of the years since, the Sharks have been easy to write off. Not in 2025-26: they reached the break with 27 wins from 55 games, already more than their 20 wins in the whole of the previous season, and they were in the thick of the Western Conference wild-card race. Even so, their playoff futures price opened around +300 before sharper money pushed it to about +220.
If you're serious about NHL futures, a break like this is when you do your homework. Below are three teams where the price, the public mood and the underlying numbers didn't line up at the break. As always, futures tie up your money for months and most of these bets lose. You're looking for prices a little better than the true chances, and there are no sure things.
How to read a futures price
Before getting to the teams, it helps to turn odds into probabilities. Positive American odds of +220 mean a $100 bet returns $220 profit, which works out to an implied probability of 100 / (220 + 100), or about 31.3%. Negative odds of -170 mean you stake $170 to win $100, which implies 170 / (170 + 100), or about 63%. A bet has positive expected value only if you believe the team's real chance is higher than the implied probability, after allowing for the bookmaker's margin. In futures, nearly everything comes down to that comparison.
New York Islanders
The latest NHL betting at Bovada had the Islanders at -170 to make the playoffs at the break. That implies about a 63% chance, so this isn't a long shot; the question is whether the market had them slightly too low or slightly too high. They aren't a glamorous team. They don't fill highlight reels, and under Patrick Roy they play a structured, low-event style that makes life uncomfortable for opponents.
That style is exactly why recreational bettors tend to overlook them. Futures markets often lean towards teams with speed, youth and offensive flair, and a side already sitting in a playoff spot that wins close, low-scoring games gets less attention. It helps to separate a team that is "currently in" from one that is "chasing": a club holding a playoff position with a veteran group only has to stay steady, with no need to go on a run. If your own estimate had them comfortably above 63%, -170 was a fair, low-variance way to hold a position. If it didn't, there was no reason to force it.
The Islanders were also a reminder that low-variance futures still carry risk. An injury to a top centre or the goaltender in March can swing a team's odds quickly, so check injury news before and after you place any futures bet.
San Jose Sharks
San Jose at +220 is where careful pricing and gut feeling parted ways. Many fans still saw a rebuilding team, and some bookmakers priced them as a likely deadline seller. The models that gave them around a 35% playoff chance saw something else.
Do the math: +220 implies just over 31%. If the true figure was nearer 35%, that's a gap of roughly three to four percentage points in the bettor's favour. That doesn't make San Jose likely to get in; on those numbers they were still more likely to miss the playoffs than make them. The price was just a little better than the chance.
The main reason was Macklin Celebrini, now in his second NHL season. An earlier version of this piece said Celebrini already has 62 points, which undersold him: by mid-February he had 81 points (28 goals and 53 assists) in 55 games, fourth in the league in scoring. A player in that kind of form, with decent goaltending and a few friendly bounces, can change a team's chances quickly over the last weeks of a season.
Celebrini had already shown a knack for big nights as a rookie. His first career hat trick came in April 2025, at the end of his first season:
MACKLIN CELEBRINI HAS HIS FIRST CAREER HAT TRICK ??? pic.twitter.com/bOx1d7Q9LO
— Sharks on NBCS (@NBCSSharks) April 10, 2025
Bettors who focus on process look for small positive edges like this and accept that many individual tickets will lose. Over a large number of bets, consistently getting a better price than the true chance is what counts; on any one bet, anything can happen. Here the idea was buying mispriced variance on the cheap and letting the result take care of itself, with a stake small enough that a losing ticket wouldn't hurt.
Nashville Predators
With Nashville at +250 we need to be more careful than the original version of this article was. Models gave the Predators roughly a 19% chance of a wild-card spot, and watching them this season backed that up: the defensive structure had frayed, the goaltending hadn't settled, and the roster was caught between ageing veterans and untested young players.
That's the problem with calling it value. +250 implies about 28.6%, well above a 19% model estimate. On those numbers the price was not in the bettor's favour; the bookmaker had the edge. The only case for Nashville was believing the models were too pessimistic.
You could argue that. Filip Forsberg was still the team's main source of offence, and when he gets hot the whole attack tends to follow. General manager Barry Trotz has a long record as a coach and executive and wasn't expected to give up on the season quietly. A compressed post-Olympic schedule rewards depth and experience, and a couple of deadline additions plus steadier goaltending could have raised the team's real chances. Those are reasons to update your own estimate, though. They don't make the gap between 19% and 28.6% go away.
Put simply, Nashville at +250 was a speculative bet that only made sense if you had good reason to think the team was much better than the models said. Without that conviction, it was a pass.
A note on futures and bankroll
Futures are fun, but your money is locked up for weeks or months and prices can move sharply against you. Keep stakes small relative to your overall budget, never bet money you need for anything else, and remember that even well-priced bets lose often. If betting stops being enjoyable, take a break, and if you're in the US and worried about your gambling, the National Problem Gambling Helpline is available on 1-800-GAMBLER.
Once the schedule restarts, you can grab our NHL picks free of charge on every game day, and check the NHL public betting trends to see which side the crowd is backing.
FAQ
What does +220 mean on a make-the-playoffs bet?
Why bet on playoff futures during the Olympic break?
Is a team that is already in a playoff spot a safe bet?
Build a streak today
15 in a row = $100 · 21 in a row = $1,500 · Free to play.
What Sports Betting Operators Should Look for in a Sportsbook PlatformNovember 4, 2026
Sports Betting Props vs Casino Side Bets: What's the Difference?October 31, 2026
South African Boxing Puts Two Title Fights on the Same November NightOctober 9, 2026