Handicapping

How to Pick Player Props: Project the Number, Then Bet the Gap

8 min read
How to pick player props: project the player's number before you look at the line

The receiver's line is 64.5 yards. He went for 112 last week, his fantasy managers are thrilled, and every highlight show ran his long touchdown. You hit the over without thinking. That's exactly the bet the sportsbook was hoping for.

To pick player props well, project the player's number yourself before you look at the line. Start with his expected minutes or snaps and his role, adjust for the matchup and likely game script, and think about the typical game rather than the average. Then compare your projection with the prop, shop for the best number, and bet only when the gap beats the juice. Do that, and you'll find yourself betting unders more often than you'd expect.

Why player prop bets are worth your time

Sportsbooks offer thousands of player prop bets every week. Game spreads get hammered by sharp money and settle into very efficient numbers. A backup running back's rushing yards in a Thursday game doesn't get that kind of attention. Lower betting limits on props mean fewer sharps bother, and more soft numbers survive. It's one of the few corners of sports betting where a careful bettor can still out-work the market.

The catch is the price. The hold on props is usually higher than on sides and totals, and books protect themselves with lower limits for a reason. You need a real edge, not a hunch, to beat a prop market that charges you more to play.

Types of prop bets you'll see

Player props are bets on an individual player's stats in one game: an NFL quarterback's passing yards, a receiver's receiving yards or receptions, a running back's rushing yards, an NBA player's points, rebounds or assists, or a pitcher's strikeouts in MLB. Game props cover things like which team scores first. Team props are usually a team's own point total. Futures props run for a whole season, such as a player's total touchdowns or an award. This guide is about the first kind, because individual player performance is where your own homework can beat the book's number most often.

Start with volume: minutes, snaps and role

Every stat starts with opportunity. A player can't catch passes if he's not on the field, and he can't score if he's not getting shots. So before efficiency, before matchups, figure out how much he'll play and what his job is.

For an NFL player prop, look at snap share, routes run, targets and carries. A receiver who runs a route on 90% of dropbacks is a much safer volume bet than one who rotates in. Target share is stickier from week to week than yards per catch, which swings with one long play.

For an NBA player prop, the player stats that matter first are minutes and usage rate. A player who's going to see 36 minutes with a 28% usage rate has a stable floor. A bench player whose minutes depend on foul trouble and blowouts does not. If you've read our piece on building NBA numbers from pace and efficiency, this is the same work at the player level.

Build your own prop projection

A simple prop projection is enough. It doesn't need to be perfect. It needs to be yours, made before the line has a chance to anchor you. Betting on player props without one is just guessing with extra steps.

Take an NFL receiver. Say you expect 8 targets, he catches about 65% of his targets, and he averages about 12 yards per catch. That's 8 × 0.65 = 5.2 catches, and 5.2 × 12 = about 62 yards. If the prop is 69.5, you're looking at the under. If it's 54.5, the over.

For an NBA scorer, start with minutes, then points per minute in his current role. 34 minutes at 0.75 points per minute is about 25.5 points. Bump it if the game projects to be fast or a teammate who takes a lot of shots is out. Trim it if the matchup is bad or the spread is big enough that he might sit the fourth quarter.

Think in medians, not averages

Most prop bettors skip this step, and it's worth more than any matchup stat.

A lot of player stats are lopsided. A receiver might have 40 yards in most games and then 150 in one. That one big game drags his average up, but it doesn't change what usually happens. His average might be 62 while his typical game, the median, is closer to 52.

The prop line is set near where the book expects about half the bets to win. If you compare it with a season average, the over will look like value far more often than it really is. Compare it with what the player does in a normal game. Rushing yards, receiving yards, and assists tend to behave this way. Points for a high-usage NBA scorer are a bit more stable, but the same idea applies. MLB player props, like a pitcher's strikeouts, start from a similar question: how many batters will he face before he's pulled?

Anytime touchdown props are the extreme case. Most players score in a minority of their games, so the "yes" is usually the longer side for a reason. Treat them as the long shots they are.

Why unders win more than people expect

Most bettors would rather root for something to happen than for it not to. Overs are more fun. Nobody screams at the TV for a running back to stay under 58.5 yards. That bias shows up in how prop lines get bet, and sometimes in how they're set.

Unders also have more ways to cash. An injury in the first quarter, a blowout that sends starters to the bench, foul trouble, an ejection, a game script that flips a team from running to passing: almost all of that hurts overs. Very little of it helps them.

Betting strategies that say "always bet unders" go too far, though. The lean does mean that if your projection is close to the line, you shouldn't be surprised that the under keeps looking right. And if you find yourself betting overs 80% of the time, check whether your numbers or your fandom are doing the picking.

Matchups and game script

Once you have a baseline, adjust for the game itself.

Defense: some teams give up a lot to slot receivers or tight ends, some shut down the run. Be careful with small samples, though. Five games of a defense allowing big numbers to tight ends may just be five good tight ends.

Game script: a team that's a big underdog will likely trail and throw more, which helps its receivers and hurts its running backs. A big favorite might run the clock in the second half. The point spread and total tell you a lot about the expected script, so use them.

Pace and environment: a high total means more plays and more chances for everyone. Wind can knock down passing numbers in football. In basketball, a fast pace adds possessions, which adds counting stats.

Injuries around the player: when a top receiver sits, someone else gets his targets. When an NBA starter is out, his minutes and shots get redistributed. These are often the best prop spots on the slate, because the book has to move many lines at once.

Shop prop odds for the best line

Prop lines vary between sportsbooks far more than game spreads do. One book might have a receiver at 58.5 and another at 62.5. On a stat with a median near 60, that's the difference between a good wager and a bad one. Shopping for the best line is the cheapest edge in prop betting, and it takes five minutes.

Price matters too. At -110 you need to win 52.4% to break even. At -130 it's 56.5%. A prop at the right line with a bad price can still be a losing bet. If you're not sure how much a price change costs you, our breakdown of spotting a price worth betting walks through the math.

Timing and news

Prop lines often post later than sides and totals, and they move hard on injury news. In the NBA especially, being early on a lineup change is where much of the edge comes from. Being early on a guess is where much of the losing comes from.

If a bet depends on a teammate sitting, wait for confirmation unless you're getting a price that makes the risk worth it. And check whether a player is likely to play his normal minutes before you bet anything that needs volume. Many books also offer live betting on player props during the game; the same projection logic applies, with less time to think.

Parlays and same-game props

Stacking props into a parlay looks great on the slip. But books know that props in the same game are often connected (a quarterback's yards and his top receiver's yards rise and fall together), and they price those combinations with that in mind. Your edge on each leg gets eaten by the extra hold.

On SportsPlays, player props are single bets only. They can't go into parlays or teasers. We think that's the right way to learn them anyway: one projection, one bet, one result you can grade.

Keep score

Props come in volume, which means you can build a sample faster than with game lines. Use that. Write down your projection, the line you got, the closing line and the result for every prop. After a few hundred, you'll know whether your projections are better than the market's, and which kinds of props you're good at. A simple sheet does the job, and our guide to keeping a clean record of every bet shows what columns to use. It's the same habit at the center of handicapping as a whole.

Props on SportsPlays

When player props are posted, they sit on their own tab for each game: NFL passing, rushing and receiving yards, receptions and anytime touchdowns on the football props page, and points, rebounds, assists, threes and points plus rebounds plus assists on the basketball props page. You can play them with your Free Bet Balance, and they count as Contest bets in the Monthly Contest as long as the price is -140 or longer.

That last rule is useful even if you never enter. Forcing yourself to skip heavily juiced props is a decent habit, because those are rarely where the value is.

SportsPlays is for players 21 and over. If betting ever stops being fun, call or text 1-800-GAMBLER for free, confidential help.

FAQ

What is the best way to pick player props?
Make your own projection for the stat before you look at the line: expected minutes or snaps, times how often the player gets the ball, times what he does with it. Then compare it with the prop and bet only when the gap is bigger than the juice.
Are overs or unders better for player props?
Unders are often the better side. Most bettors like rooting for big games, a lot of yardage and points stats are lopsided so the typical game lands below the average, and injuries or blowouts cut playing time. That's a lean, not a rule: bet the side your number supports.
What stats should I look at for NFL player props?
Snap share, targets or carries, routes run, and the matchup against the defense. For NFL props, volume is the most stable thing you can measure; yards per catch and touchdowns bounce around a lot more.
What should I look at for NBA player props?
Projected minutes, usage rate, pace of the game and who is out. When a teammate sits, his minutes and shots go somewhere, and that's where most of the NBA's best prop spots come from.
Can you parlay player props?
At many sportsbooks, yes, but the payout on correlated props is usually trimmed and the edge shrinks fast. On SportsPlays, props are single bets only: they can't go into parlays or teasers.

Build a streak today

15 in a row = $100 · 21 in a row = $1,500 · Free to play.

Join free

More from Handicapping