Handicapping

Sports Handicapping: What It Is, How It Works and How to Get Good at It

6 min read
Sports handicapping: the 52.4% a handicapper needs to beat

Sports handicapping is working out which bet on a game is worth making, if any. A handicapper looks at stats, injuries, matchups, travel and the betting line, comes up with what they think should happen, and compares it with what the sportsbook expects. When the two are far enough apart, that's a bet. When they aren't, it's a pass, and good handicappers pass a lot.

The word comes from horse racing, where a handicapper assigns extra weight to the better horses to even out a race. In sports betting the "handicap" is the point spread, the number that evens out two unequal teams. Handicapping is deciding whether that number is right.

What does a sports handicapper actually do?

Every handicapper is chasing the same thing: beating the betting line often enough to cover the bookmaker's fee. At standard -110 odds that means winning more than 52.4% of the time. Anything under that loses money over a season, however smart the analysis sounds.

The people doing it range widely. There are recreational handicappers studying games for their own bets or for contests, and professional bettors who do it for a living and mostly keep quiet about it. There are pick sellers, often called touts, who sell picks by the day, week or season, and free services and media experts who give picks away to build an audience. And more and more, there are computer handicappers who build models that turn data into a predicted score. We go through each kind, and how each gets paid, in what a sports handicapper is.

The handicapping process in 5 steps

1. Start with the line

The betting line is the market's best guess, shaped by a huge amount of money. Before you form an opinion, know the spread, the total and the moneyline, and how each has moved since it opened. Line movement shows you where the money went.

2. Make your own number

Now estimate the game yourself. Power ratings are the classic way to do it: give each team a rating, add something for home field (roughly 1.5 to 2.5 points in today's NFL, less than it used to be), and the difference is your spread. Computer models do the same thing with a lot more data.

3. Adjust for what the numbers miss

Injuries come first, especially a quarterback in football or a star in basketball. Then rest and travel, like back-to-backs in the NBA and NHL or short weeks in the NFL. Weather matters for football and baseball totals. So do motivation, and matchups where one team's strength runs right into the other's weakness.

4. Compare and decide

If your number and the line are close, pass. Most games should be passes, and that's the hardest habit to learn. Bet only when the gap means something. In the NFL, a line sitting on the wrong side of a key number like 3 or 7 matters far more than a half point anywhere else.

5. Track everything

Write down every pick: date, sport, bet, line, odds, stake and result. After a few hundred you'll know which sports and bet types you're actually good at. Our guide on keeping a betting record has a sample sheet. Almost everyone is surprised by what their records show, and usually not pleasantly.

Sports handicapping by sport

SportWhat matters most
NFLQuarterback health, key numbers (3, 7), rest and short weeks
College footballTalent gaps, motivation, coaching changes, weather
NBARest days, star availability, pace for totals
College basketballHome court, tempo, depth in conference play
MLBStarting pitchers, bullpen fatigue, ballpark and weather
NHLStarting goalie, back-to-backs, special teams

How to judge a handicapper (or a picks service)

Before you follow anyone's picks, free or paid, look at their record the way a skeptic would. It should be complete and public, with every pick posted before the game, losers included. A record that only shows the hot streaks is hiding the rest.

The sample has to be big. Fifty picks proves almost nothing; five hundred starts to mean something. The results should be in units won, not just wins and losses, because a 60% record on -200 favorites can still lose money. That's what return on investment in betting measures. And the best quick test of all is whether their picks beat the closing line. And the numbers have to be believable. Long-term records above about 58% against the spread are very rare, so "80% winners" is a sales pitch, not a record. Anyone who guarantees a winner is selling, not handicapping.

Free picks vs. paid sports handicapping services

You don't have to pay for good sports picks. Plenty of the best sports handicappers to follow post free picks and best bets with their full records. A paid sports handicapping service is only worth it if its verified record beats what you'd do on your own once you take off the subscription. A professional sports handicapper selling a $50 "lock of the week" needs to win a lot of your wagers just to cover the fee.

We'd use free expert picks, computer picks and consensus numbers as a second opinion. If your handicapping and the experts agree, good. If they don't, figure out why before you bet.

Can you make money handicapping?

Some people do. Most don't. Because of the vig, someone flipping a coin loses about 4.5% of everything they bet. To beat that you need a real edge, the discipline to pass on most games, sensible bet sizes, and the patience to ride out losing streaks that even good handicappers go through.

That's why we think the best way to learn is without risking money. Test your process over a few hundred picks first and let the record tell you whether it works. If you want to take it further, here's the route to becoming a handicapper, including how people realistically earn from it.

More on handicapping

Each of these goes deeper on one part of the craft:

Practice handicapping free on SportsPlays

SportsPlays runs free sports handicapping contests on real lines: point spreads, moneylines and totals on the NFL, college football, NBA, college basketball, MLB, NHL and more. Your record is tracked for you, you go up against other handicappers on the handicapping leaderboard, and the best of them win cash. You can check your numbers against a model with our model picks and against the public with our public pick percentages.

SportsPlays is for players 21 and over. If betting ever stops being fun, call or text 1-800-GAMBLER for free, confidential help.

FAQ

What does a sports handicapper do?
A sports handicapper studies games (stats, injuries, matchups, schedules and betting lines) to decide which bets are worth making. Some handicap for themselves; others sell their picks or give them away to build a following.
Is sports handicapping illegal?
Analyzing games and sharing or selling picks is legal in the US. Whether you can place bets on those picks depends on where you live, since sports betting laws are set state by state. Free handicapping contests involve no wagering at all.
How much does a sports handicapper make?
It varies hugely. A handicapper betting for themselves earns whatever edge they have over the vig, which for most people is nothing or less. Pick sellers earn from subscriptions, which says more about their marketing than their record.
What winning percentage is good for a handicapper?
Against the spread at -110, 52.4% is break-even. Over hundreds of picks, 55% is very good and 57-58% is excellent. Anyone claiming 70% or more over a long stretch deserves a hard look at their records.

Build a streak today

15 in a row = $100 · 21 in a row = $1,500 · Free to play.

Join free

More from Handicapping