Handicapping

How to Handicap Baseball: Pitchers, Bullpens, Parks and Price

7 min read
How to handicap baseball: start with the pitching matchup, finish with the price

The ace is on the mound, he's 12-3 with a 2.70 ERA, and the line is only -150. Free money, right? Then you look closer. His strikeout rate is down, his walk rate is up, he's been lucky on balls in play, and the bullpen behind him threw 14 innings in the last three days. Suddenly -150 doesn't look so cheap.

To handicap baseball, start with the starting pitchers, judged on strikeouts, walks and stats like FIP rather than ERA and wins. Then check each bullpen's quality and recent workload, the lineups each pitcher will face, and the ballpark and weather. Turn all of it into your own price for each team, convert that to a moneyline, and bet only when the sportsbook's number gives you an edge. Baseball betting rewards patience: a 162-game season, small edges, and a lot of noise in any single game.

Why baseball is a different kind of handicap

Football and basketball are spread sports. Baseball is a moneyline sport, and that shapes all of MLB handicapping. You're mostly betting on who wins, and the odds tell you what the market thinks each team's chances are. A -150 favorite is priced to win 60% of the time. A +130 underdog, about 43.5%.

That changes how you think. Your job is to estimate a win probability for each team and compare it with the price. If you think a team wins 60% and you can get it at +100 (50% implied), that's a big edge. If you think 60% and the price is -170 (63% implied), it's a pass, however good the pitcher is.

It also means MLB is full of underdogs worth betting. In baseball, even bad teams beat good teams all the time. The best team in the league loses dozens of games every season. If you've read our case on why plus-money sides deserve a fair look, baseball is where it applies most.

Grade the starting pitchers properly

The starting pitcher is the biggest single factor in an MLB game, and the place where casual bettors make the most mistakes.

Win-loss record tells you almost nothing about a pitcher. It depends on his offense, his bullpen and luck. ERA (earned run average) is better but still noisy, because it includes defense and balls that fall in or don't.

Look at what the pitcher controls. Strikeout rate and walk rate are the backbone: a pitcher who strikes out a lot of hitters and doesn't walk many is usually good, whatever his ERA says this month. FIP (fielding independent pitching) and xFIP build an ERA-like number from strikeouts, walks and home runs, and they predict future ERA better than ERA itself. If a pitcher's ERA is well below his FIP, he's probably been lucky and is due to regress. If it's well above, he may be a buy.

Context matters too. How deep does he usually go? A starter who rarely gets through five innings hands more of the game to the bullpen. Is his velocity down? Is he coming back from injury? Has he faced this lineup three times already this season?

Then look at the bullpen

The starter might throw five or six innings. Someone has to get the other nine to twelve outs. A good starter in front of a bad bullpen is a riskier favorite than his name suggests.

Two things to check. First, quality: the same strikeout, walk and FIP-type numbers you'd use for a starter, for the relievers who pitch high-leverage innings. Second, workload: how many innings and pitches the bullpen threw over the last two or three days. If the closer and top setup man have pitched three days in a row, they might not be available tonight, and the line may not fully reflect it.

Lineups, handedness and matchups

MLB lineups come out a few hours before first pitch, and they matter. Teams rest regulars on day games after night games, against tough pitchers, or just to give someone a break. One missing star bat moves a line less than in basketball, but several regulars sitting can be worth real money. When you size up a lineup, look past batting average to how often hitters get on base and hit for power; those numbers tell you more about runs.

Handedness is the other piece. Most hitters do better against pitchers who throw from the other side. A lineup loaded with left-handed hitters against a right-handed starter is a different matchup from the same lineup against a left-hander. Check team splits against left-handed or right-handed pitching, and remember that teams often adjust their lineup to the opposing starter.

Ballparks and weather

No sport cares about the venue like baseball. Fences are different distances, outfields are different shapes, and the air is different from city to city.

Coors Field in Denver is the famous one: the thin air at altitude helps fly balls carry and makes breaking pitches break less, so scoring there runs high. Other parks play toward pitchers. Totals usually account for the park, but you need to know it too, or you'll think every Rockies home game total is too high.

Weather is the daily variable. Wind blowing out to center can turn fly balls into home runs, and wind blowing in can kill them, especially in parks that are open to the wind. Hot, humid air helps the ball carry; cold air in April and October holds it down. If you bet totals, check the forecast after the line comes out, not just when you first look.

Home plate umpires have different strike zones too. It's a smaller effect than wind or the park, but a pitcher-friendly zone can shave a little off a total.

Turning it into a price

All of that has to become a number. Start with each team's overall strength, then adjust for tonight's starters, bullpen availability, lineups and park. Say you land on the home team winning 58% of the time. A fair moneyline for 58% is about -138. If the sportsbook has the home team at -125 (55.6% implied), you have an edge of a couple of percentage points. If it's -155 (60.8%), you don't.

Those edges look tiny next to a football spread that's three points off. That's normal. In baseball, a 2 or 3 percentage point edge is a good bet, and over a full season those add up. It also means bet sizing matters more than people think, which is why we lean on a fractional Kelly approach to sizing rather than betting the same amount on every game.

The price you pay matters as much as the pick. Some sportsbooks deal baseball on a 10-cent line (say -150 on the favorite and +140 on the underdog), while others charge more. Over a full season of betting on baseball, the cheaper line is worth real money, so shop before you wager.

Moneyline, run line, totals and first five

The moneyline is the purest way to bet your read: you're predicting a winner and getting a price for it.

The run line is baseball's point spread, almost always -1.5 for the favorite and +1.5 for the underdog. It doesn't create value by itself, it shifts the price. A -180 favorite might be around +110 on -1.5. Whether that's better depends on how likely you think the favorite is to win by two or more, and a lot of one-run games say it's less often than people assume.

Totals are where the park, weather, umpire and bullpens all come together. They're a good market for bettors who do the daily homework.

First five innings bets (F5) cover only innings one through five. They mostly take the bullpen out of it. If you love one starter and hate the bullpen behind him, the F5 line lets you bet what you actually handicapped.

Long-season discipline

Baseball's schedule is a grind: a game almost every day for six months, from spring into the fall. That's a lot of chances to bet, and a lot of chances to bet too much.

Don't bet every game. Even professional MLB bettors pass on most of the board. On a full 15-game slate, most nights you'll find a few with a real gap between your number and the market, and a lot that are close. Pass on the close ones, and size the bets you do make against your bankroll, not your mood. Stringing three favorites into parlays every night is the fastest way to give back a good month.

Don't overreact to streaks. A team on a winning streak isn't necessarily better than it was a week ago; it may have played bad teams with its best pitchers lined up. Recent form matters a bit, but much less than the pitching matchup in front of you.

Keep records and judge yourself over hundreds of bets, not weeks. With prices near even money, a 54% winner and a 50% winner can look identical for a month. Looking at your return on every dollar risked over a full season tells you which one you are.

Trying it on SportsPlays

During the season, every game's moneyline, run line and total is on the daily MLB odds page, and the starters-only market has its own tab of first five innings lines. Before you bet, you can see which MLB teams the crowd is backing to know where the public money is likely going, and compare your read with the expert baseball pick we open up free each day. All of it fits into our broader handicapping method; baseball just adds pitchers, parks and a much longer season.

If we had to pick one habit for a new baseball handicapper, it would be this: look up the starter's strikeout and walk numbers before his ERA, every single time.

SportsPlays is for players 21 and over. Play responsibly, and if you think you have a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER for free, confidential help.

FAQ

What is the most important factor in handicapping an MLB game?
The starting pitching matchup, judged on stats that predict well (strikeout rate, walk rate, FIP or xFIP) rather than ERA or win-loss record. After that come the bullpens, the lineups each pitcher will face, and the ballpark.
What's the best stat for handicapping MLB pitchers?
No single stat does it all, but strikeout rate minus walk rate and FIP-type stats are more predictive than ERA, which gets bent by defense and luck on balls in play. Use a few together and give recent seasons more weight.
Is it better to bet the moneyline or run line in baseball?
Most baseball handicappers work mainly with moneylines, because they price exactly what you're predicting: who wins. The run line (-1.5 or +1.5) changes the price, not the value. Bet whichever gives you the better number for your read.
What is a first five innings bet?
A bet on just the first five innings, so the starting pitchers decide most of it and the bullpens barely matter. It's useful when you like a starting pitching matchup but don't trust one team's relievers.
How much do ballparks and weather affect baseball totals?
A lot, compared with other sports. Some parks play much friendlier to hitters than others, with Coors Field in Denver the extreme. Wind blowing out or in can move a total, and hot air carries the ball farther than cold air.

Build a streak today

15 in a row = $100 · 21 in a row = $1,500 · Free to play.

Join free

More from Handicapping