Betting on Underdogs vs. Favorites: Which Side Actually Pays Over Time?
Everybody knows two guys. One only bets favorites, because "the best team usually wins." The other only bets underdogs, because "that's where the money is." Give them both a full season and they usually end up in the same place: down, and each sure the other one is the idiot.
Betting on underdogs vs. favorites isn't a choice that makes or loses money by itself. Favorites win more often and pay less; underdogs win less often and pay more; the sportsbook builds its margin into both. Over time, the only side that pays is the one priced wrong, and that can be either. If you want a lean, underdogs offer more value a bit more often, mainly because the betting public loves favorites. But "a bit more often" is a long way from "always."
How the odds define favorites and underdogs
The favorite is the team more likely to win. On a moneyline it has negative odds, like -150, meaning you risk $150 to win $100. The underdog is the team expected to lose, with plus odds like +130, meaning a $100 bet wins $130: less likely to cash, bigger potential payout.
With a point spread, the favorite gives points and the underdog gets them. If the Eagles are -7 against the Giants, the Eagles have to win by more than 7 to cover the spread. The Giants cover if they lose by fewer than 7 or win the game outright. So an underdog can lose the game and still win your bet, which is why spread underdogs and moneyline underdogs are two different things.
The math: what each price has to win
Every price comes with a break-even win rate, the share of bets you need to win just to get back to zero. Here's what a $100 bet pays at common moneyline odds, and how often it has to win:
| Odds | Profit on a $100 bet | Break-even win rate |
|---|---|---|
| -300 | $33.33 | 75.0% |
| -200 | $50 | 66.7% |
| -150 | $66.67 | 60.0% |
| -110 | $90.91 | 52.4% |
| +110 | $110 | 47.6% |
| +150 | $150 | 40.0% |
| +200 | $200 | 33.3% |
| +300 | $300 | 25.0% |
Now picture a favorite at -200 that wins 65% of the time. It wins most nights, feels safe, and loses money: on $100 a bet you average 0.65 × $50 − 0.35 × $100 = −$2.50 per bet. An underdog at +200 that wins 35% of the time loses most nights, feels awful, and makes money: 0.35 × $200 − 0.65 × $100 = +$5 per bet.
Win rate tells you how a bet feels; the price tells you whether it pays. We go deeper on this in our guide to betting ROI, which is the number that settles every favorites-or-underdogs argument.
Pros and cons of betting the favorite
Betting favorites gives you a smoother ride. You win more often, losing streaks are shorter, and your bankroll moves in small steps. If you're new, that's easier to live with, and there's nothing wrong with backing a favorite you've priced correctly.
The catch is the payout. At -300, one loss erases three wins. A heavy favorite also hides its risk well: a 75% chance of winning still means it loses one time in four, and a four-game cold stretch is not unusual. The worst version of favorite betting is the parlay of "sure things": three -300 favorites feel like a lock, and all three win together only about 42% of the time even if each one really is 75%.
And heavy favorites are where the margin is easiest to hide. A couple of cents of extra juice on a -400 line is hard to notice, and it adds up.
Pros and cons of betting the underdog
Underdogs pay more than you risk, so you don't need to win most of your bets to make money. A bettor hitting 45% on +130 underdogs is in profit. One good week can make up for a bad one, and every win feels like a small heist.
The price of that is variance. Underdogs lose more often than they win, so long losing streaks are normal, even for a bettor with a real edge. Ten losses in a row on +200 dogs will happen to you eventually. If your bankroll or your nerves can't handle that, size your bets down. Our page on Kelly bet sizing shows why the right stake on a long shot is smaller than most people think.
Long shots have their own trap. In many betting markets, horse racing being the classic case, big long shots tend to be overbet because people love a big payout. A +600 dog is often a worse bet than it looks, and most long shots are underdogs for a reason. The sweet spot for most underdog bettors is short and mid-range dogs, not lottery tickets.
When underdogs offer more value
The betting public leans toward favorites, popular teams and overs. Sportsbooks know it, and in heavily bet games they can shade the line a little toward the popular side. That leaves the underdog slightly better priced than it should be. It's not a huge edge and it's not every game, but it's the main reason underdog betting gets its reputation. Our guide to betting against the public covers when that works and when it's just contrarian for the sake of it.
Situations worth a closer look:
- Big national games, like NFL primetime matchups, where public betting on the popular favorite is heaviest.
- Teams coming off an ugly, heavily televised loss. The market tends to overreact to one bad game.
- NFL underdogs at +3.5 or +7.5, where the hook puts you on the right side of a key number. Our guide to NFL key numbers explains why those half points matter.
- Home underdogs. A classic angle that many handicappers watch, though the market has caught up to most of it.
- Low-scoring sports. Underdogs win outright more often in hockey, baseball and soccer than in the NFL or NBA, because one goal or one run decides so many games. The NBA is the opposite: the better team wins more often, so big NBA underdogs rarely win outright and more of their value is in the points.
Before you trust any of these, check what the public is actually doing. The free consensus page shows which side most bettors are on for each game.
When favorites are the better bet
Favorites aren't the sucker side. When an underdog has a story everybody loves (a popular team, a hot quarterback, a revenge game), the public can push money onto the dog and leave the favorite underpriced. Injury news can do the same: the market sometimes overreacts to a missing player and drops a favorite's price further than it should.
Timing matters, too. Public money tends to show up close to game time and tends to back favorites, which can make favorites more expensive by kickoff. That's why a lot of bettors like to bet favorites early and underdogs late. It doesn't happen every time, so watch the live odds instead of assuming.
Spread or moneyline for underdogs?
With an underdog you like, you can usually take points on the spread or bet the moneyline for a bigger payout. If you believe the dog keeps it close, take the points. If you believe the dog wins outright, the moneyline pays more. In the NFL, a short underdog of +1.5 to +2.5 is often worth taking on the moneyline, because the spread only saves you on a 1- or 2-point loss. A big underdog of +10 is different: a lot of its value lives in the points, and its moneyline at +400 needs an upset.
For favorites it's the reverse question: is the favorite good enough to cover, or only to win? Laying -7 on a team you think wins by 4 is a losing bet with a winning team.
Our take: bet the price, not the side
We'd never tell anyone to be a favorites bettor or an underdog bettor. Be a price bettor. Make your own number, convert it to a win probability, and compare it with the break-even rate in that table. If the favorite needs 66.7% and you think it wins 72% of the time, bet the favorite. If the dog needs 40% and you think it wins 45%, bet the dog. Most of the time, neither side is far enough off, and you pass. That's what finding value bets looks like in practice. Any betting strategy that picks a side before looking at the price is just a habit.
Then track it. Split your results into favorites and underdogs and you'll find out which ones you're actually good at, which is rarely the one you'd guess.
In the SportsPlays Monthly Contest, every Contest bet has to be at -140 or longer, so heavy favorites are off the table anyway. A contest leaderboard rewards upside, and that's where well-chosen underdogs earn their keep. You can see how it plays out in this month's standings.
SportsPlays is for players 21 and over. If betting ever stops being fun, call or text 1-800-GAMBLER for free, confidential help.
FAQ
Is it better to bet on favorites or underdogs?
Is betting on underdogs profitable?
Can you make money only betting favorites?
Can an underdog cover the spread and still lose the game?
Should you bet underdogs early or late?
Build a streak today
15 in a row = $100 · 21 in a row = $1,500 · Free to play.
Would Your AI Football Picks Survive a Public Leaderboard?November 17, 2026
How to Handicap NHL Games: A Hockey Betting Guide to Goalies, Shot Quality and PriceNovember 17, 2026
How to Handicap College Basketball: A Step-by-Step Tempo-Free MethodNovember 16, 2026